This editorial appears in Volumes 4, 5, and 6 and is
intended briefly to apologize for the delay in publication of these
volumes, to announce that Gary Olson assumes duties as Editor for Volumes
7-12 (with a new Board), and to comment on various aspects of founding
a journal in composition studies. Also, Karen Spear has assumed the
position of Managing Editor for Volumes 4-12, an essential administrative
function. In fact, Karen Spear's agreeing to serve, as much as any factor,
enabled the publication of Volumes 4-6 and assured the future of the
JAC through Volume 12 and beyond. Contributions
should be sent to Gary Olson, and subscription matters addressed to
Karen Spear. Succeeding Gary Olson and Tom Brennan as Book Review Editor
is Kristin Woolever, who can be addressed on that subject. See inside
back cover for all addresses.
JAC will continue to use anonymous peer review
to decide on publication of articles submitted; Gary Olson has already
set up a system that will produce a decision on acceptance within two
months, a major improvement. As Editor, he has strong support from the
University of South Florida, as does Karen Spear from the University
of Utah. Northeastern University supports Kristin Woolever's work with
book reviews. Thus the leadership represents the South, the West, and
the East, a three-legged stool with stability.
JAC would not exist if it were not for substantial
financial support from the University of South Alabama. The idea for
JAC was mine; I had been asked to edit a newsletter
for a newly formed Association of Teachers of Advanced Composition (ATAC)
in 1979, but arbitrarily decided to make it something more. I was teaching
advanced composition, knew of little scholarly literature on the subject,
and thought a journal might be more likely to provide some expert advice
than a newsletter. In other words, I assumed my own interests were more
general than those reflected in the newsletter idea. Since then, ATAC
has withered away, perhaps like the state in a Marxist myth, and JAC
has survived.
I believe that in light of my modest talents as an editor and student
of composition studies, I have done as much as I can do. I am happy
to turn over the leadership of the JAC to those
more deeply engaged than I in this nascent field of English studies.
Not only are those three named—Olson, Spear, and Woolever—much
more talented and accomplished in this field than I, but the new Board
promises to reflect excellence on a national basis: Lynn Bloom, Joseph
Comprone, Edward Corbett, Frank D'Angelo, Bertie Fearing, David Foster,
Maxine Hairston, James Kinneavy, Cy Knoblauch, Janice Lauer, Elaine
Maimon, Richard Marius, Lee Odell, Frank O'Hare, Marilyn Sternglass,
Stephen Tchudi, Joseph Trimmer, Joseph Williams, and Ross Winterowd.
Credit for assembling this Board belongs entirely to Gary Olson. Perhaps
the focus of this group is not as restricted to advanced composition
as is the case with the original Board, but breadth of interests can
help the JAC.
I hope that the JAC continues to explore the
teaching of writing beyond the freshman level. Often it is difficult
to obtain good articles on this subject, but the existence of the journal
should provide both a stimulus and an opportunity. We need a journal
that focuses on advanced writing more than we need another general writing
journal.
Were I to provide advice to someone beginning a journal, I would remind
myself that people and money come first. Thus, I am particularly grateful
to the original Board, especially Bernice Dicks, and to my University,
especially the Dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, for funding.
Then I would say that one cannot be both editor and Managing Editor
at once, much less be Editor and/or Managing Editor without a regular
year-round reduction in teaching duties. To proceed on this basis is
to burn the candle at both ends and in the middle—I know because
I found out the hard way. In fairness, I report that in six years I
did receive a one-course reduction in teaching for a single quarter
for JAC editing. Finally, a graduate assistant
would be essential; at various times I was assigned work-study students
who were charming and wonderful people, but those with the skills soon
found better paying term-time jobs. As for the others, as I say, they
were charming and wonderful. The four graduate assistants in my department
were promised to our writing lab as a condition for a large grant from
NEH; their exclusive use for tutoring made them indentured servants
in a grammar ghetto, and unavailable for helping me edit a journal.
So, to the prospective editor, I say that departmental support is as
essential as the funding which normally derives from one's dean or vice
president. Departmental support may be more difficult to come by than
funding, so I would caution.
It would, of course, be a pity for someone of genuine talent to have
experienced my founding-editor's blues, but in my case it probably doesn't
matter all that much. The pool of melted wax which I had become (you
must spend a summer in Mobile) underwent some sort of metamorphosis,
so phoenix-like I arose, giving me hope to projects yet unattempted.
In fact, just the other day my Dean, observing that my newly feathered
form was perhaps a bit plump about the equator, asked if it represented
growth or decay. Either way, I hope the JAC
prospers so we might help our students to build more stately mansions,
or at least to erect a decent shelter efficiently.